| Complaint Case No. CC/17/960 |
| | | | 1. Prasad | | S/o Late Musalaiah R/at Srinidhi Nilaya, No.15,13th A Cross, Vyalikaval Bangalore.03 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/963 |
| | | | 1. Shivanna J | | R/at No.4769/47,3rd Cross,Shamanna Layout,B.G Road,Gottigere,B-83 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/964 |
| | | | 1. K.Girijakumari | | W/o M.Krishnappa, Aged about 60yrs, No.21,Saisobhagu, 1st Floor,1st Main Road,2nd Cross, Vivekananda Colony, Kanakapura Main Road,B-78 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/965 |
| | | | 1. Prasanna R | | R/at No.6,6th Cross, Anandagiri Extension,SSA Road, Hebbal,Bangalore-32 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/966 |
| | | | 1. Pushpalatha | | W/o Nagraj,No.90,1st Main,5th Cross,Gangondanahalli Main Road,Nayandanahalli B-39 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/968 |
| | | | 1. Seethamma | | R/at No.90,1st Main,5th Cross, Ganganadanahalli Main Road, Nayandanahalli post,B-39 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/969 |
| | | | 1. K.Mahanthesh | | R/at No.135,Gowramma, Building,Jayanna Layout,Indlabele Road,Attibele,B-107 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/970 |
| | | | 1. Anil Kumar S | | S/o Shivananda Murthy p R/At No.871/17,8th Cross,9th Main, Banashankari 3rd Stage,1st Block, Srinagar,B-50 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/971 |
| | | | 1. Srikantaraje Urs | | R/at No.159, Kashinagar, Yalachanahalli, B-78 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/973 |
| | | | 1. Padmavathi | | R/at No.217,1st Main, 8th Cross,K.H Ranganatha Colony, opp BHEL,Mysore Road,B-26 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/974 |
| | | | 1. Ramya A.R.A | | R/at No.12/C,17th Main,AGS Layout, Subramanyapura post,B-61 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/975 |
| | | | 1. Prakash Bilamkar | | R/at No.107/108, 1st Floor,1st Cross,1st main Vijaya Bank Colony, Basvanapura main road,K.R Puram, B-36 R/by GPA Holder Nagaraj Bilamkar | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/976 |
| | | | 1. Prakash Bilamkar | | S/o late Babu Rao.B R/at No.107/108,1st Floor,1st Cross,1st Main,Vijaya bank Colony,Basavanapura Main Road,K.R Puram,B-36 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/977 |
| | | | 1. Latha K | | D/o M.Krishnappa, R/at No.21, Saisobhagu 1st floor,1st Main Road,2nd Cross,Vivekananda Colony,Kanakapura Main road,B-78 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/978 |
| | | | 1. Venkatesh | | S/o Ramanujaiah, No.224,Ranganatha Colony,opp BHEL,Mysore Road, B-26 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/979 |
| | | | 1. Prasanna R | | S/o Ramachandar, No.6,6th Cross,Anandageri Extension,SSA road,Hebbal,B-32 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/980 |
| | | | 1. Karthik.K | | S/o Krishnamurthy.R No.227,D.S Max Swastik,Paduka Mandira Road, Thurahalli,B-61 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/981 |
| | | | 1. Venkatesh | | S/o Ramanujaiah, No.224,Ranganatha Colony,opp BHEL Mysore Road,B-26 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
| | Complaint Case No. CC/17/982 |
| | | | 1. Devaraja B.A | | S/o Annappa Gowda T.H, No.143/3,C/o Ravi Sushilamma,BSV Nilaya,2nd Cross, Nagawara post,1st Main,Thanisandra, Near Ananda Bhavan Hotel,Manjunatha Layout,B-45 | | Bangalore | | Karantaka |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. TGS Construction pvt Ltd | | R/by Mandeep kaur Managing Director, W/o Sachin Nayak, D/o Harjit Sing No.L-142, 5th Avenue Ground floor, 5th Main Road,6th Sector,HSR Layout,Bangalore-102. | | Bangalore | | Karnataka |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
|
|
| Final Order / Judgement | Complaints Filed on:17.05.2017 | Disposed On:24.10.2017 |
BEFORE THE DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM AT BANGALORE URBAN 24th DAY OF OCTOBER 2017 PRESENT:- | SRI. P.V SINGRI | PRESIDENT | | SMT. M. YASHODHAMMA | MEMBER | | SMT. P.K SHANTHA | MEMBER |
COMPLAINT Nos.960/2017, 963/2017, 964/2017, 965/2017, 966/2017, 968/2017, 969/2017, 970/2017, 971/2017, 973/2017, 974/2017, 975/2017, 976/2017, 977/2017, 978/2017, 979/2017, 980/2017, 981/2017 & 982/2017. |
Complaint No.960/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prasad, S/o Late Musalaiah, Aged about 47 years, R/at “Srinidhi Nilaya” No.15, 13 ‘A’ Cross, Vyalikaval, Bangalore-560003. | Complaint No.963/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Shivanna J, S/o Late Javarashetty, Aged about 45 years, R/at No.4769/47, 3rd Cross, Shamanna Layout, B.G Road, Gottigere, Bangalore – 560083. | Complaint No.964/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.K.Girijakumari, W/o M.Krishnappa, Aged about 60 years, R/at No.21, Saisobhagu, 1st Floor, 1st Main Road, 2nd Cross, Vivekananda Colony, Kanakapura Main Road, Bangalore-560078. | Complaint No.965/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prasanna R, S/o Ramachandar, Aged about 42 years, R/at No.6, 6th Cross, Anandageri Extension, SSA Road, Hebbal, Bangalore-560032. | Complaint No.966/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.Pushpalatha, W/o Nagraj, Aged about 48 years, R/at No.90, 1st Main, 5th Cross, Ganganadanahalli Main Road, Nayandanahalli Post, Bangalore-560039. | Complaint No.968/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.Seethamma, W/o Late Narayanappa, Aged about 56 years, R/at No.90, 1st Main, 5th Cross, Ganganadanahalli Main Road, Nayandanahalli Post, Bangalore-560039. | Complaint No.969/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.K.Mahanthesh, S/o K.Kottrappa, Aged about 35 years, R/at No.135, Gowramma Building, Jayanna Layout, Indla Bele Road, Attibele, Bangalore-562107. | Complaint No.970/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Anil Kumar S, S/o Shivananda Murthy P, Aged about 33 years, R/at No.871/17, 8th Cross, 9th Main, Banashankari III Stage, 1st Block, Srinagar, Bangalore-560050. | Complaint No.971/2017 COMPLAINANT | Srikantaraje Urs, S/o Nanjunda Raje Urs, Aged about 41 years, R/at No.159, Kashinagar, Yalachanahalli, Bangalore-560078. | Complaint No.973/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.Padmavathi, W/o N.Ramachandra, Aged about 36 years, R/at No.217, 1st Main, 8th Cross, K.H Ranganatha Colony, Opp. BHEL, Mysore Road, Bangalore-560026. | Complaint No.974/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.Ramya R.A, W/o Shivananda G.K, Aged about 34 years, R/at No.12/c, 17th Main, AGS Layout, Subramanyapura Post, Bangalore-61. | Complaint No.975/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prakash Bilamkar, S/o Late Babu Rao B, Aged about 44 years, R/at No.107/108, 1st Floor, 1st Cross, 1st Main, Vijaya Bank Colony, Basavanapura Main Road, K.R Puram, Bangalore-560036. Rep. by GPA Holder, Nagaraj Bilamkar. | Complaint No.976/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prakash Bilamkar, S/o Late Babu Rao B, Aged about 44 years, R/at No.107/108, 1st Floor, 1st Cross, 1st Main, Vijaya Bank Colony, Basavanapura Main Road, K.R Puram, Bangalore-560036. Rep. by GPA Holder, Nagaraj Bilamkar. | Complaint No.977/2017 COMPLAINANT | K.Latha, D/o M.Krishnappa, Aged about 33 years, R/at No.21, Saisobhagu, 1st Floor, 1st Main Road, 2nd Cross, Vivekananda Colony, Kanakapura Main Road, Bangalore-560078. | Complaint No.978/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Venkatesh, S/o Ramanujaiah, Aged about 62 years, R/at No.224, Ranganatha Colony, Opp. BHEL, Mysore Road, Bangalore-560026. | Complaint No.979/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prasanna R, S/o Ramachandar, Aged about 42 years, R/at No.6, 6th Cross, Anandageri Extension, SSA Road, Hebbal, Bangalore-560032. | Complaint No.980/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.K.Karthik, S/o Krishnamurthy R, Aged about 32 years, R/at No.227, D.S Max Swastik, Paduka Mandira Road, Thurahalli, Bangalore-560061. | Complaint No.981/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Venkatesh, S/o Ramanujaiah, Aged about 62 years, R/at No.224, Ranganatha Colony, Opp. BHEL, Mysore Road, Bangalore-560026. | Complaint No.982/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Devaraja B.A, S/o Annappa Gowda T.H, Aged about 33 years, R/at No.143/3, C/o Ravi Sushilamma, BSV Nilaya, 2nd Cross, Nagawara Post, 1st Main, Thanisandra, Near Ananda Bhavan Hotel, Manjunatha Layout, Bangalore-560045. Advocate – Sri.V.Lakshmi Kanth Rao. V/s. | opposite party | TGS Constructions Pvt. Ltd., Rep. by Mandeep Kaur, Managing Director, Aged about 26 years, No.L-142, 5th Avenue, Ground Floor, 5th Main Road, 6th Sector, HSR Layout, Bangalore City - 560102. |
COMMON ORDER SRI. P.V SINGRI, PRESIDENT All these complaints have been filed by various complainants U/s.12 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 against one and same the Opposite Party (herein after referred as OP). The issues involved in all these complaints are one and the same and the reliefs sought in each of the complaints are almost identical. Hence all these complaints have been taken up together for disposal under this common order. 2. The complainants have filed these complaints for refund of the advance amount paid by each one of them towards purchase of Flats/sites together with interest, compensation and litigation cost etc., alleging deficiency of service. 3. The allegations made in all these complaints are almost same. The brief averments made in all these complaints are as under: That OP is a Company registered under the Companies Act and one Mandeep Kaur is Managing Director of the said Company. OP is engaged in construction of apartments and development of residential layout. That OP Company gave vide publicity regarding their various projects through celebrities in the print as well as electronic media. That OP by their hi-tech and glittering advertisements attracted complainants and several other innocent persons who were looking for residential sites and apartments in various locations at Bangalore. Attracted by various offers made by OP Company, complainants decided to buy sites/apartments in various projects proposed to be developed by OP Company in prime areas at different locations. That, OP made the complainants to believe that they have either purchased or entered into memorandum of understanding with the owners of various lands upon which they proposed to develop/construct residential sites and apartments. Some of the complainants decided to purchase residential sites in various residential layouts to be developed by OP in different names and some of the complainants decided to purchase apartments of various dimensions, according to their requirements in different apartment complex to be developed by OP. The particulars of the advance amount paid by each of the complainants, the date of each payment, date of MOU, name of the project in which they have invested money etc., have been given in detail in the following table. Sl
No. | Complaint Number | Name of the project | Plot/ Apartment type & dimension | Total consideration amount | Amount Paid | Date | Date of MOU | 1) | 960/2017 | TGS Beijing | 650 sq. ft 1 BHK | Rs.1200000/- | 1)Rs.100000 2)Rs.200000 3)Rs.137500 | 20.03.2016 24.03.2016 14.04.2016 | 21.03.2016 | Rs.437500 | 2) | 963/2017 | TGS Vinayaka | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 Site) | Rs.780000/- | 1)Rs.1000002)Rs.200000 | 11.12.2014 21.01.2015 | 02.02.2015 | Rs.300000 | 3) | 964/2017 | TGS Meenakshi | 1200 sq. ft (20x30 Site) | Rs.600000/- | 1)Rs.100000 2)Rs.500000 | 27.02.2016 27.02.2016 | 28.02.2016 | Rs.600000 | 4) | 965/2017 | TGS Beijing | 650 sq. ft 2 BHK | Rs.1250000/- | 1)Rs.100000 2)Rs.262500 3)Rs. 75000 | 25.03.2016 05.04.2016 16.04.2016 | 26.03.2016 | Rs.437500 | 5) | 966/2017 | TGS Gayathri | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 Site) | Rs.1040000/- | Rs.100000 Rs.100000 Rs.320000 | 25.11.2015 30.11.2015 14.12.2015 | 26.11.2015 | Rs.520000 | 6) | 968/2017 | TGS Gayathri | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 Site) | Rs.1040000/- | Rs.300000 Rs.220000 | 25.11.2015 14.12.2015 | 22.11.2015 | Rs.520000 | 7) | 969/2017 | TGS Parvathi | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 Site) | Rs.930000/- | 1)Rs.100000 2)Rs.150000 3)Rs.215000 | 24.01.2016 06.02.2016 06.03.2016 | 18.01.2016 | Rs.465000 | 8) | 970/2017 | TGS Om Township | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 Site) | Rs.400000/- | Rs.200000 | 24.09.2016 | - | 9) | 971/2017 | TGS Saraswathi | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 Site) | Rs.750000/- | 1)Rs.100000 2)Rs.275000 | 18.01.2016 01.02.2016 | - | Rs.375000 | 10) | 973/2017 | TGS Bhaygalakshmi | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 Site) | Rs.900000/- | 1)Rs.125000 2)Rs.150000 3)Rs. 75000 | 01.07.2016 28.07.2016 17.08.2016 | 03.07.2016 | Rs.350000 | 11) | 974/2017 | TGS Brisbane | 600 sq. ft 1 BHK | Rs.900000/- | 1)Rs.100000 2)Rs.120000 3)Rs.180000 4)Rs. 50000 | 23.12.2015 08.01.2016 08.01.2016 05.02.2016 | 24.12.2015 | Rs.450000 | 12) | 975/2017 | TGS Athens | 700 sq. ft 1 BHK | Rs.1600000/- | 1)Rs. 50000 2)Rs. 50000 3)Rs.100000 | 21.02.2016 28.02.2016 10.03.2016 | - | Rs.200000 | 13) | 976/2017 | TGS Athens | 700 sq. ft 1 BHK | Rs.1000000/- | 1)Rs. 50000 2)Rs. 50000 3)Rs.100000 | 21.02.2016 28.02.2016 10.03.2016 | - | Rs.200000 | 14) | 977/2017 | TGS Meenakshi | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 site) | - | 1)Rs.292000 2)Rs.200000 | 27.02.2016 30.01.2016 | 31.01.2016 | Rs.492000 | 15) | 978/2017 | TGS Lakshmi | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 site) | Rs.520000 | 1)Rs.150000 2)Rs.110000 | 31.08.2015 13.09.2015 | 31.08.2015 | Rs.260000 | 16) | 979/2017 | TGS Beijing | 650 sq. ft 2 BHK flat | Rs.1250000/- | 1)Rs.100000 2)Rs.262500 3)Rs. 75000 | 25.03.2016 05.04.2016 19.04.2016 | 26.03.2016 | Rs.437500 | 17) | 980/2017 | TGS Gowri | 1500 sq. ft (30x50 site) | Rs.1200000/- | 1)Rs.300000 2)Rs.200000 3)Rs. 50000 4)Rs. 50000 | 31.10.2015 22.10.2015 20.10.2015 18.10.2015 | 25.12.2015 | Rs.600000 | 18) | 981/2017 | TGS Lakshmi | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 site) | Rs.520000/- | 1)Rs.150000 2)Rs.110000 | 31.08.2015 13.09.2015 | 31.08.2015 | Rs.260000 | 19) | 982/2017 | TGS Saraswathi | 1200 sq. ft (30x40 site) | Rs.725000/- | 1)Rs. 50000 2)Rs.100000 3)Rs. 50000 4)Rs.162500 | 11.04.2015 02.05.2015 01.06.2015 15.06.2015 | 23.05.2015 | Rs.362500 |
The complainants have advanced huge amounts towards purchase of sites/apartments and after receipt of the same, OP Company has entered into memorandum of understanding with complainants and also issued receipts for having received money from the complainants. The complainants who parted with huge amount towards purchase of sites/apartments were waiting for OP to complete the project within the time stipulated in the memorandum of understanding. However OP did not commence either the formation of any of the layouts as promised and also construction of any apartment complex. OP also started avoiding the complainants when they began repeatedly asking them about the commencement and completion of formation of the layout and construction of apartment complex. When OP failed to commence the formation of layout as well as construction of apartments, the complainants became suspicious about the bonafides of OP and their enquiries revealed that OP Company has neither purchased any of the lands shown to them nor entered with memorandum of understanding with the owners of any such lands. Then the complainants insisted OP to refund the advance amount paid. That, OP has not at all refunded any advance amount to any of the complainants despite their repeated requests. Therefore, the complainants having felt cheated by OP have approached the jurisdictional police and lodged complaints against OP. The jurisdictional police have registered cases against OP under various provisions of Indian Penal Code and issued FIR and now the investigation of the cases, has been taken up by CID Police, Bangalore. Thereafter, the complainants got issued legal notice through their counsel to OP for refund of advance amount, however the legal notices so sent were returned without service, since OP had shut down their office. Therefore, the complainants have approached this Forum for redressal. 4. Despite service of notices, OP failed to appear and were placed ex-parte. Thereafter complainants were called upon to tender their evidence by way of affidavit. Accordingly, each of the complainants have tendered their evidence by way of affidavit reiterating the allegations made in their respective complaints. Each of the complainants have produced the copies of booking form, MOU and cash receipts to substantiate the allegations made in their complaints. 5. Perused the allegations made in each of the complaints, various documents produced by the complainants and other material placed on record. The allegations made in the complaints coupled with documents produced by each of the complainants and the sworn testimony of the complainants goes to establish that, OP has lured the complainants to invest in their bogus projects and made them to part with huge advance amount knowing fully well that they are not at all able to commence or complete any one of the proposed projects announced/undertaken by them. It appears to us that, OP has played fraud upon the complainants and cheated them and also duped them. An inference can be drawn from the conduct of OP in remaining absent despite service of notice that they admit the claim of each one of the complainants. We don’t have any reasons to disbelieve or discredit oral as well as documentary evidence led in by each of the complainants. 6. The conduct of OP in not commencing and completing any of the proposed projects and failing to refund the advance amount, when demanded, certainly amounts to grave deficiency of service. The complainants who have invested their hard earned money for purchase of sites/apartments must have been put to great inconvenience and mental agony. OP has absolutely no right to retain the advance amount paid by each of the complainants after having failed to commence/complete the proposed projects. Therefore, OP has to be directed to refund the amount received from each of the complainants together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of actual receipt till the date of realization. Further OP has to be directed to pay adequate compensation to each of the complainants for having caused them great inconvenience and mental agony together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/- to each one of them. 7. In view of the discussions made above, we proceed to pass the following: O R D E R The complaint Nos.960/2017, 963/2017, 964/2017, 965/2017, 966/2017, 968/2017, 969/2017, 970/2017, 971/2017, 973/2017, 974/2017, 975/2017, 976/2017, 977/2017, 978/2017, 979/2017, 980/2017, 981/2017 & 982/2017 are filed by the complainants U/s.12 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 are allowed in part. The OP in complaint No.960/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.4,37,500/- (Four Lakhs Thirty Seven Thousand Five Hundred Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.50,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.963/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.3,00,000/- (Three Lakhs Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.35,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.964/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.6,00,000/- (Six Lakhs Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.65,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.965/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.4,37,500/- (Four Lakhs Thirty Seven Thousand Five Hundred Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.45,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.966/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.5,20,000/- (Five Lakhs Twenty Thousand Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.55,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.968/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.5,20,000/- (Five Lakhs Twenty Thousand Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.55,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.969/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.4,65,000/- (Four Lakhs Sixty Five Thousand Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.50,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.970/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.2,00,000/- (Two Lakhs Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.25,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.971/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.3,75,000/- (Three Lakhs Seventy Five Thousand Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.40,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.973/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.3,50,000/- (Three Lakhs Fifty Thousand Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.40,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.974/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.4,50,000/- (Four Lakhs Fifty Thousand Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.50,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.975/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.2,00,000/- (Two Lakhs Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.25,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.976/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.2,00,000/- (Two Lakhs Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.25,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.977/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.4,92,000/- (Four Lakhs Ninety Two Thousand Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.50,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.978/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.2,60,000/- (Two Lakhs Sixty Thousand Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.30,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.979/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.4,37,500/- (Four Lakhs Thirty Seven Thousand Five Hundred Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.50,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.980/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.6,00,000/- (Six Lakhs Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.65,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.981/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.2,60,000/- (Two Lakhs Sixty Thousand Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.30,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. The OP in complaint No.982/2017 is directed to refund a sum of Rs.3,62,500/- (Three Lakhs Sixty Two Thousand Five Hundred Only) to the complainant together with interest @ 18% p.a from the date of receipt till the date of realization. Further OP shall pay compensation of Rs.40,000/- together with litigation cost of Rs.4,000/-. OP shall comply the said order within four weeks from the date of communication of the order. Furnish free copy of this order to both the parties. This original order shall be kept in complaint No.960/2017 and a copy of it shall be placed in other connected files. (Dictated to the Stenographer, got it transcribed and corrected, pronounced in the Forum on this 24th day of October 2017) MEMBER MEMBER PRESIDENT Vln* COMPLAINT Nos.960/2017, 963/2017, 964/2017, 965/2017, 966/2017, 968/2017, 969/2017, 970/2017, 971/2017, 973/2017, 974/2017, 975/2017, 976/2017, 977/2017, 978/2017, 979/2017, 980/2017, 981/2017 & 982/2017. |
Complaint No.960/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prasad, Bangalore-560003. | Complaint No.963/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Shivanna J, Bangalore – 560083. | Complaint No.964/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.K.Girijakumari, Bangalore-560078. | Complaint No.965/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prasanna R, Bangalore-560032. | Complaint No.966/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.Pushpalatha, Bangalore-560039. | Complaint No.968/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.Seethamma, Bangalore-560039. | Complaint No.969/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.K.Mahanthesh, Bangalore-562107. | Complaint No.970/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Anil Kumar S, Bangalore-560050. | Complaint No.971/2017 COMPLAINANT | Srikantaraje Urs, Bangalore-560078. | Complaint No.973/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.Padmavathi, Bangalore-560026. | Complaint No.974/2017 COMPLAINANT | Smt.Ramya R.A, Bangalore-61. | Complaint No.975/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prakash Bilamkar, Bangalore-560036. Rep. by GPA Holder, Nagaraj Bilamkar. | Complaint No.976/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prakash Bilamkar, Bangalore-560036. Rep. by GPA Holder, Nagaraj Bilamkar. | Complaint No.977/2017 COMPLAINANT | K.Latha, Bangalore-560078. | Complaint No.978/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Venkatesh, Bangalore-560026. | Complaint No.979/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Prasanna R, Bangalore-560032. | Complaint No.980/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.K.Karthik, Bangalore-560061. | Complaint No.981/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Venkatesh, Bangalore-560026. | Complaint No.982/2017 COMPLAINANT | Sri.Devaraja B.A, Bangalore-560045. V/s. | opposite party | TGS Constructions Pvt. Ltd., Rep. by Mandeep Kaur, Managing Director, Bangalore City - 560102. |
Witnesses examined on behalf of the complainant/s dated 25.09.2017. 1) | Sri.Prasad, complaint No.960/2017. | 2) | Sri.Shivanna J, complaint No.963/2017. | 3) | Smt.K.Girijakumari, complaint No.964/2017. | 4) | Sri.Prasanna R, complaint No.965/2017 | 5) | Smt.Pushpalatha, complaint No.966/2017. | 6) | Smt.Seethamma, complaint No.968/2017. | 7) | Sri.K.Mahanthesh, complaint No.969/2017. | 8) | Sri.Anil Kumar S, complaint No.970/2017. | 9) | Srikantaraje Urs, complaint No.971/2017. | 10) | Smt.Padmavathi, complaint No.973/2017. | 11) | Smt.Ramya R.A, complaint No.974/2017. | 12) | Sri.Prakash Bilamkar, complaint No.975/2017. | 13) | Sri.Prakash Bilamkar, complaint No.976/2017. | 14) | K.Latha, complaint No.977/2017. | 15) | Sri.Venkatesh, complaint No.978/2017. | 16) | Sri.Prasanna R, complaint No.979/2017. | 17) | Sri.Karthik. K, complaint No.980/2017. | 18) | Sri.Venkatesh complaint No.981/2017 | 19) | Sri.Devaraja B.A, complaint No.982/2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.960/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 21.03.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of police complaint dated 15.01.2017. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 20.03.2016 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 14.04.2016 for Rs.1,37,500/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of legal notice dated 10.04.2017. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.963/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form dated 11.12.2014. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 02.02.2015. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of cancellation form dated 29.01.2017. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.964/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.7143 dated 27.02.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 28.02.2016. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 27.02.2016 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 27.02.2016 for Rs.5,00,000/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy cancellation form dated 31.01.2017. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.965/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.7278 dated 25.03.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 26.03.2016. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 25.03.2016 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 05.04.2016 for Rs.2,62,500/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of receipt dated 16.04.2016 for Rs.75,000/-. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy cancellation form dated 24.01.2017. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of police complaint. | 8) | Document No.8 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 9) | Document No.9 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.966/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.5487 dated 25.11.2015. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 26.11.2015. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 14.12.2015 for Rs.3,20,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 25.11.2015 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy cancellation form dated 22.02.2017. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of police complaint. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 8) | Document No.8 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.968/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.5439 dated 20.11.2015. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 22.11.2015. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 25.11.2015 for Rs.3,00,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 14.12.2015 for Rs.2,20,000/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of cancellation form dated 22.02.2017. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of police complaint. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 8) | Document No.8 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.969/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.6408 dated 17.01.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 18.01.2016. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 24.01.2016 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 06.02.2016 for Rs.1,50,000/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of receipt dated 06.03.2016 for Rs.2,15,000/-. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.970/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.9876 dated 24.09.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of receipt dated 24.09.2016 for Rs.2,00,000/-. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy cancellation form dated 12.01.2017. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of police complaint. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of legal notice dated 15.04.2017. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.971/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.6424 dated 17.01.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of receipt dated 18.01.2016 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy receipt dated 01.02.2016 for Rs.2,75,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of legal notice dated 10.04.2017. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.973/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.8846 dated 01.07.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 03.07.2016. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of cancellation form dated 23.01.2017. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.974/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 24.12.2015. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of receipt dated 23.12.2015 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 08.01.2016 for Rs.1,20,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 08.01.2016 for Rs.1,80,000/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of receipt dated 05.02.2016 for Rs.50,000/-. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of cancellation form dated 10.07.2017. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of police complaint dated 20.03.2017. | 8) | Document No.8 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 9) | Document No.9 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.975/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.7217 dated 21.02.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of receipt dated 21.02.2016 for Rs.50,000/-. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 28.02.2016 for Rs.50,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 10.03.2016 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of special power of attorney. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.976/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.7223 dated 21.02.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of receipt dated 21.02.2016 for Rs.50,000/-. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 28.02.2016 for Rs.50,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 10.03.2016 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of special power of attorney. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.977/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 31.01.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of receipt dated 27.02.2016 for Rs.2,92,000/-. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 30.01.2016 for Rs.2,00,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of cancellation form dated 31.01.2017. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.978/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 31.08.2015. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of receipt dated 11.09.2015 for Rs.2,20,000/-. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of cancellation form dated 23.01.2017. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.979/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.7277 dated 25.03.2016. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 26.03.2016. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 25.03.2016 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 05.04.2016 for Rs.2,62,500/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of cancellation form dated 24.01.2017. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of police complaint dated 15.01.2017. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 8) | Document No.8 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.980/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.4941 dated 18.10.2015. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 25.12.2015. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 31.10.2015 for Rs.3,00,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 22.10.2015 for Rs.2,00,000/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of receipt dated 20.10.2015 for Rs.50,000/-. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of receipt dated 18.10.2015 for Rs.50,000/-. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of police complaint dated 18.03.2017. | 8) | Document No.8 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 9) | Document No.9 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.981/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 31.08.2015. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of cancellation form dated 23.01.2017. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 11.09.2015 for Rs.2,20,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Documents produced by the complainant:
(Complaint No.982/2017) 1) | Document No.1 is copy of booking form No.1801 dated 09.04.2015. | 2) | Document No.2 is copy of MOU executed between OP and complainant dated 23.05.2015. | 3) | Document No.3 is copy of receipt dated 11.04.2015 for Rs.50,000/-. | 4) | Document No.4 is copy of receipt dated 02.05.2015 for Rs.1,00,000/-. | 5) | Document No.5 is copy of receipt dated 01.06.2015 for Rs.50,000/-. | 6) | Document No.6 is copy of receipt dated 15.06.2015 for Rs.1,62,500/-. | 7) | Document No.7 is copy of cancellation form dated 23.01.2017. | 8) | Document No.8 is copy of police complaint dated 24.03.2017. | 9) | Document No.9 is copy of legal notice dated 20.04.2017. | 10) | Document No.10 is copy of paper publication dated 15.07.2017. |
Witnesses examined on behalf of the Opposite party - Nil Documents produced by the Opposite party – Nil MEMBER MEMBER PRESIDENT Vln* | |
